In the Fall of 2019 Great West Engineering, in conjunction with Montana Fish Wildlife & Parks (MTFWP) and Trout Unlimited (TU), successfully designed and installed the first fish ladder in Great West’s history. The new fish ladder was installed on Mill Creek, near Frenchtown, MT. The Mill Creek watershed is a tributary of the Clark Fork River and provides important spawning and rearing habitat for Rainbow, Brown and Cutthroat trout. An existing concrete check dam is located approximately 4,000 feet upstream from the confluence with the Clark Fork River.
The concrete check dam was constructed as a diversion structure for the nearby King Ranch Golf Course to assist in their irrigation needs. To facilitate fish passage over the concrete check dam, in the 1990’s a concrete fish ladder was installed on the downstream face of the check dam. The original concrete fish ladder was constructed of unreinforced concrete and was in poor condition. Multiple retrofits to improve the function of the original fish ladder were implemented with limited success.
The existing check dam could not be removed for implementation of the new fish ladder, so the new structure had to be designed for modular installation to assist in field fitting the structure. Upon evaluation of multiple alternatives, a steel modular structure was concluded to best fit the project needs. The modular nature of the steel structure allowed for easier installation in the wet site conditions, as dewatering methods were limited. It also allowed for installation using small equipment. No crane, concrete truck, or specialized equipment was needed for installation.
Original Fish Ladder Structure
Finished Fish Ladder
What creates the step or “ladder” effect in the fish ladder structure are a series of baffles which deflect flow within the structure. These baffles are used to create areas of high velocity, which encourage fish passage, while also creating areas of low velocity, creating slack water for fish to rest. Two main baffle configurations were evaluated for the fish ladder, straight and alternating baffles. The figure, 3D Model comparison of Alternating vs Straight Baffles, performed by the Institute of Hydraulic Research-IPH, clearly demonstrates the higher velocities (shown in red/pink) present in the straight baffle configuration. An alternating baffle configuration was ultimately concluded to be the best configuration for this site, as it produced a larger reduction of flow velocities within the structure.
3D Model Comparison of Alternating vs Straight Baffles
Fish Ladder in Action!
A major factor during design of the fish ladder was the maximum velocity at the baffle location. This is known as an “attractant velocity”. The “attractant velocity” needs to be high enough to encourage fish movement up the fish ladder, but not so high that is prevents certain size classes of fish from movement upstream. To determine a baffle configuration that would operate with the existing flow regime, while also meeting the constraints for fish passage, a one-dimensional hydraulic model was developed.
The one-dimensional model provided tools to analyze multiple fish passage opening widths, structure lengths, structure slopes, and number of baffles to determine their respective influence on the velocities within the structure. As seen in the figure titled, Fish Ladder Flow Profiles, the steps within the ladder are clearly defined form multiple flow events.
Do You Own or Operate a Public Water System?
If you own or operate a public water system, then you need to know and understand the changes to the Lead and Copper Rule (LCR). The changes are being implemented by the EPA to further strengthen the LCR and better protect public health through the following: Lead...
What is a Resident Project Representative and Why is it Important?
What is a Resident Project Representative (RPR) and what benefits do they bring to a project or the Owner? Some see an on-site inspector or RPR as “just another hard hat sitting in a pick-up or leaning on a shovel” and a “necessary evil”. This is far from reality,...
ROSE Award Winners – 2023 Yearly
We are pleased to announce our latest ROSE Award winners! Announced at Great West's annual holiday party at Fairmont Hot Springs, we can't say thank you enough for the effort and hard work each of these valued team members has put forth. Based on votes by their...